The indian penal code ipc dowry law misuseipc 498a by indian women. Preserving call details, exemption from personal appearance etc have been most helpful for fighting matrimonial litigation. In the last 20 years of criminal law reform a common argument made against laws relating to violence against women in india has been that women misuse these laws. This section was inserted so that a woman can live with dignity in her matrimonial place. To challenge misuse of any law, it is necessary to build up data of mis use as well as related court decisions in support of the challenge. Increasing number of false cases of dowry harassment against the husbands is now become so serious that the government of india is proposing to amend sec 498a to make the offence as.
The sc order on sec 498a addresses the demands of mens. Supreme court of india has modified its directions issued in rajesh sharma case for preventing misuse of section 498a of indian penal code. Hc gives guidelines on section 498a hyderabad news times. Petition praying for amendments in section 498a of ipc pdf. A newspaper headline such as above is sure to garner sympathy for the victim from the public and the media. I hope to shed some light on what this law is really about, the effects it will have on you and your family and how to survive this ordeal. Report misuse of section 498a ipc please fill this form, we will try to respond as soon as possible. Nov 21, 2016 ipc 498a commonly known as the antidowry act. Points on ipc 498a law, misuse, future pil for dowry law misuse etc. Misuse of section 498a ipcjudicial trend by karan godara ssrn. May 26, 2019 section 498a ipc 498a ipc, ipcsection498a, misuse of section 498a, 498a misuse read 498a quash judgments 498a quash judgment 06.
The dangerous, false myth that women routinely misuse. No arrests under antidowry law without magistrates nod. It is a cognizable, nonbailable, and noncompoundable offence. Nri press conference misuse of dowry law 498a 09 aug07. How can indian men legally protect themselves from women. Download my free pdf ebook surviving the legal jungle dont be a lone ranger. Misuse of 498a is legal terrorism supreme court of india posted on geek upd8. Official statistics about misuse of 498a released statistical analysis of victim complaints received by 498a. The apex court in a judgment said courts are there to.
Supreme court judgment on misuse of section 498a of ipc. Misuse of section 498a ipc and dowry prohibition act visavis human rights. Ma r r i a g ei st h ev o l u n t a r yu n i o nf o rl i f eo fo n ema na n do n ewo ma nt o t h e e x c l u s i o n o fa l lo t h e r s. Supreme court to revisit its judgment on misuse of section. The flip side of section 498a, however, is its alleged misuse, where, as the bench of justices ak goel and uu lalit noted in the current sc order, women invoke it to harass and intimidate their. Sep 14, 2018 the court said that section 498a s misuse to harass the other side too is causing social unrest. A doctrinal research on section 498a ipc, 1860 a critical. Home ministrys advisory lettercircular to stateut to curb misuse of ipc 498a and arrest by police 9 aug 2014 by videv 6 comments after a recent supreme court judgment to prevent arbitrary arrests under ipc 498a, the home ministry has sent a letter to all states and union territories informing and advising them about the same judgment. The petitioner in his petition has pointed out the extensive abuse and misuse of this provision of the penal code. Misuse of dowry laws is not a recent phenomenon and the judiciary of india is totally responsible for the growing misuse of dowry law and. A critical study on misuse of section 498a of indian penal code, 1860 1a.
Misuse of 498a is legal terrorism supreme court of india. If a woman is subjected to cruelty by her husband or any relative of her husband, then whoever responsible for the cruelty shall be punished with imprisonment, which is nonbailable, perceptible, and noncompoundable. The highhanded behaviour of the laws and the breakup of the marriage has another side. Pdf misuse of section 498a ipc and dowry prohibition act visa. Zee crime files video on misuse of 498a july 30th 2006 watch the interviews of victims of 498a misuse. Section 498a of the indian penal code ipc has become i. Another draconian law got passed, ex wife will get 50% of the inherited properties in addition to 50% of the property of husband. Men are not money minting machines, husbands are not sperm donors. Messers, i was reading some of your articles which exposed a lot of everyday injustices, when it occurred to me that i should request you to study and report the misuse of the indian anti dowry and harassment lawsdp act and section 498a of ipcindian penal code, which is ruining many nri lives along with citizens living in india. The supreme court on thursday issued a new set of directions to prevent the misuse of section 498a of indian penal code. The silent tears of shattered families the ugly reality of. Doc misuse of section 498a in indian society rahul. Punish false 498a and human beings who put false cases. December 7, 2014 woman lodges a complaint under section 498a, husband and inlaws arrested.
How to save yourself and your family from getting into 498a mess. These applications may be used in court proceedings to seek various reliefs which a lay man may not be aware. A critical study on misuse of section 498a of indian penal. Misuse of section 498 a ipc and dowry prohibition act visavis human rights. Parliament had introduced section 498a in ipc in 1983 to deal with increasing number of dowry deaths while categorising the offence as cognisable and nonbailable.
Judgments and opinions on 498a, misuse of laws etc. Supreme court dipak misra dowry human rights section 498a. Every law is inserted to cure suffering and to check if people are subjected to social evil. This will encourage women to file 498a case at drop of hat, so if you are not 100% sure of marrying your girl, you may want to get into a live in relationship. Description download misuse of section 498a ipc comments. Sc judgement on section 498a ipc highlighting misuse of law against husbands 2018. Domestic violence act and section 498a has been heavily being misused. Doc a doctrinal research on section 498a ipc, 1860 a. Myneni, legal research methodology 1 allahabad law agency, 5th ed. The silent tears of shattered families the ugly reality of dowry law ipc 498a.
For example, the ssary ipc 498a was enacted to lend protection to as neceweak and uninformed women,as they were unable. Unfortunately, the formulation of this law left a host of loopholes for exploitation and abuse. Home ministrys advisory lettercircular to stateut to. Collection of 498a and dowry related news articles 12 mb pdf. Pdf domestic violence act 2005 and section 498 a of indian.
Misuse of 498a is legal terrorism supreme court of india posted on geek upd8 law blog thanks to advocate lekhraj sharma. Points on ipc 498a law, misuse, future pil for dowry law. Misuse of dowry laws is not a recent phenomenon and the judiciary of india is totally responsible for the growing misuse of. T os t a r twi t hf i r s tweh a v et ol o o kt h a twh a tt h i swo r dma r r i a g eme a n s. Therefore research article would be dealing with the section 498a of ipc the claimed misuse in present context along with the arguments of the accused side. Need for statutory changes by prof dr mukund sarda. Section 498a of the indian penal code, is a criminal offence. The law explains that cruelty means anything that is done on purpose, and either causes serious harm to. Most important 498a judgments that positively shaped the indian judicial system and helped fight and protect against unlawful dowry act 498a cases. But we often misuse the laws, which amounts to the constitutional validity. This is a tool which is being used only to extort money, to beg a better deal from the marriage. Apr 12, 2020 498a quash judgments in year 2020 7 cases where courts quashed 498a fighting 498a misuse read the blog.
Malimath committee report on misuse of section 498a there are some laws in indian penal code like section 498 a, other sections under chapter xxa of cruelty and domestic violence act, 2005 etc. Discuss about mens issues and telecast in media that includes television, internet and other possible telecasting ways. The charge of misuse is made particularly against offence of dowry death in section 304b and sec 498a of the ipc without dealing with grassroot realities. Pdf misuse of ipc section 498a harish a c academia. It also helped the researcher to know the historical background regarding the insertion of the provision under indian penal code, 1860. Kannappan 1saveetha school of law, saveetha institute of medical and technical sciences. Mar 11, 2020 how to quash 498a recent judgment 498a quashing 04. The indian penal code ipc dowry law misuseipc 498a by. State of upa two judge bench of justices ak goel and uu lalit observed that section 498a was inserted in the statute with the laudable object. We provide all services of drafting and vetting of legal. This section will solely be invoked by wifedaughterinlaw or her relative. The apex court in a judgment said courts are there to protect harassed husbands and their relatives. It makes it a crime to be cruel to your wife or to your relatives wife.
Application templates applications against 498a misuse. I think 498a is non compoundable means that your wife can not withdraw the case. The dangerous, false myth that women routinely misuse domestic cruelty laws. Misuse of 498a and other false cases on men will extinct if above two points are met 4.
Join our facebook group to connect read this free ebook written by fathers involved in child custody issues. But some of them file fake affair to put their inlaws in trouble. Apr 26, 2016 supreme court judgment on misuse of section 498a of ipc by. Supreme court of india on thursday has issued new set of directions to prevent the misuse of section 498a of indian penal code. A critical study on misuse of section 498a of indian penal code, 1860. Dowry, section 498a, indian penal code, misuse, cruelty. Oct, 2017 in an important development, a threejudge bench of the supreme court today observed that it is not in agreement with the courts judgment rendered in rajesh sharma v union of india, in which it had laid down safeguards to prevent misuse of section 498a of the indian penal co. Jan 20, 2015 it is no hidden secret that ipc 498a is a weapons of human rights abuse of husband and his familyrelatives, and judiciary including supreme court has given instances of its gross misuse and directives to government and law ministry for prevention of ipc 498a misuse and amendments. Start your daily mornings with times of india newspaper. Pdf domestic violence act 2005 and section 498 a of indian penal. In most cases 498a complaint is followed by the demand of huge amount of money extortion to settle the case out of the court. People dont know what section 498a of the ipc is nor do they know what to do when a 498a case is registered against them. The abovestated book helped the researcher in finding out relevant caselaws related to section 498a ipc and cases where misuse has occurred. Report on section 498a ipc law commission of india.
This prompted the womens rights movement in the 1970s and 80s to undertake an unrelenting campaign to bring marital cruelty under the ambit of the. In comparison, complaints declared false on similar grounds are far higher in other ipc cases such as for cheating, kidnapping and abduction, criminal breach of trust. Section 498a of indian penal code section 498a, introduced in 1983 is popularly referred to as the dowery law that seeks to safeguard married ladies from harassment by the spouse or his relatives. Download fulltext pdf domestic violence act 2005 and section 498 a of indian penal code. Sc verdict on misuse of sec 498a is antiwomen share, save, comment the conviction rate of cases under section 498a was 21.
Significance of this judgement is that the misuse of 498a has been recognised again and direction to establish family welfare committee has been made and stop on immediate arrest have been directed. Modern women are stated to misuse the section 498a of the indian penal code. Just take the print out of the following letters in the. This law, easily the most misused law in india, is meant to provide criminal relief against the physical and mental abuse caused to women by their husbands and inlaws. Misuse of 498a ipc sc judgement preeti gupta case family law. Section 498 a is a cognizable offence under the indian penal code, 1860 and was brought into the ipc in the year 1983 to curb the menace of cruelty to married women for want of dowry, which often led to their deaths. What are the counter steps for the misuse of ipc 498a.
On the 27th of july 2017, the supreme court of india issued a series of guidelines to curb the misuse of the draconian ipc 498a. Judgments and opinions on 498a, misuse of laws etc men. Kannappan 1saveetha school of law, saveetha institute of medical and technical sciences, saveetha university, chennai. New trend to misuse and its remedy article pdf available february 2018 with 4,518 reads. The court said that section 498a s misuse to harass the other side too is causing social unrest. Lodging of cases with the crime against women cell may not be genuine. Advisory on measures to be taken by statesuts to curb misuse of section 498a of ipc. An investigative report created for public awareness. Supreme court modifies its order on dowry harassment the.
Part 1 of the zee crime files program on misuse of ipc 498a 107 mb part 2 of the zee crime files program on misuse of ipc 498a 63 mb part 3 of the zee crime files program on misuse of ipc 498a 44 mb advertizement of the zee crime files program on misuse of ipc 498a 7 mb. At the same time the inherent logical flaws in the law must be brought out and focused. The dowry prohibition act, 1961 failed to address the various forms of abuses meted out to married women, and the alarming increase of dowry deaths. Mens rights activist, state agencies and even the supreme court seem to. Fight against misuse of dowry law ipc498a get free. Curtailing the scope of section 498a can have dangerous consequences for women who anyway find it hard to fight for their legal. This article is being put in public domain and can be used by anyone in part or full for any purpose whatsoever. How to quash 498a recent judgment 498a quashing 04.
The rajesh sharma judgment with new guidelines to be followed in ipc 498a cases was pronounced in 2017 by a two judge bench, and it was much celebrated by some people and hailed as a pathbreaking judgment, as if following of those guidelines would automatically take away all fear of arrest, roping in of all family members, or the possibility of facing criminal trial in indian system for 510. A doctrinal research on section 498a ipc, 1860 a critical analysis. Supreme court latest judgments on 498a in 2019 indian. Letter to moia minister about false 498a and red corner notices dec 17th 2006.
634 1238 848 546 922 659 359 1279 1235 69 394 475 1054 1458 186 692 514 921 345 1399 1458 401 1066 440 1418 186 563 581 810 225 4 1295 241 1537 1341 1126 333 404 825 139 1208 546 1058 622 418